Interview with the Curator







Nancy Mowll Mathews is the Eugénie Prendergast Senior Curator of 19th and 20th Century Art at the Williams College Museum of Art. She directs the Prendergast Archive and Study Center at WCMA, conducting ongoing research and organizing exhibitions and publications on the Prendergasts and their era (1850-1950). She is the co-author of two catalogues raisonnés: Mary Cassatt: The Color Prints (1989) and Maurice Brazil Prendergast, Charles Prendergast: A Catalogue Raisonné (1990) and is currently president of the Catalogue Raisonné Scholars Association.


WCMA: How did you come up with the idea for this exhibition?

NM: I knew from our research on the Prendergast catalogue raisonné that Maurice Prendergast owned stock in a film company before 1912. I thought this was a curious thing for him to do, so I started searching for more information—what film company, what was his connection to the movies, etc.? The more I looked into the history of early cinema, the more parallels I found between his work and the films made at the turn of the century. And furthermore, there were parallels between these films and the work of other artists of the Impressionist and Ash Can schools of painting in America. Before long I was wishing I could see the paintings and the films side-by-side, and voilà, an exhibition was born! I never did find out what film company he had stock in . . .

WCMA: How long have you been researching the project ?

NM: I started this project about ten years ago. These kinds of things take a long time.

WCMA: What makes this exhibition so special or different from other exhibitions you’ve curated in the past?

NM: The biggest difference from my past research and exhibitions is working with film, which is an entirely new medium for me. I had to learn not only a whole new history of visual culture at the turn of the century but a new vocabulary and a new set of issues in exhibiting this medium in a gallery.

WCMA: It’s atypical to show films in painting galleries, isn’t it?

NM: This has become more common as contemporary artists explore new ways of thinking about and displaying video art. I am borrowing from contemporary art installations to show older art in a new way. While film purists might object to seeing the films in any other way than a theatrical projection (which we will also have as part of the exhibition), I would like to point out that many 1890s devices, including the kinetoscope, were similar to the monitors we will have in our galleries. So you see that our installation has important historical precedents as well.

This exhibition is also different because of the iconic nature of some of the works that we are borrowing. These are some of the most famous works of American art, and we are putting them into an entirely new artistic context—that of the moving pictures of their era.

WCMA: What, for you, are some of the highlights of the exhibition?

NM: As you walk through the exhibition, you will see paintings and films hung side-by-side—that in itself will be a highlight. Some of my favorite juxtapositions are: a film of the bodybuilder Eugen Sandow with academic drawings (such as by John Singer Sargent) of ideal male models, views of Venice by a Lumière filmmaker alongside watercolors of the same subject by Maurice Prendergast, a turn of the century bathing beach by John Sloan compared to an Edison film, and the crowds of New York in paintings by George Luks and George Bellows beside films of the same bustling streets.


WCMA: What do you hope people will take away after they see this exhibition?

NM: My hope is that in this exhibition people will suddenly begin to see familiar films and paintings in a new way. Impressionism and Ash Can paintings are very well studied, and even the films from this period are well known. But when they are joined together they both take on new meanings. The lesson I learned is that the art forms do not have firm boundaries but are constantly interacting and inspiring mutual creativity—thus changing the way we see and interpret the world.